How to Choose Your Self-Tan Shade: Glazed, Latte, or Tomato Girl?

The internet has quietly sorted the summer glow into three girls: glazed, latte, and tomato. One of them is you - the only question is which. Think of this as your shade horoscope, except the science is real and the outcome is entirely in your control. Because the truth about a natural-looking tan isn't the depth you pick. It's the undertone.

First, the one rule that matters: undertone before depth

Every "why did I go orange" story starts the same way - someone chose a shade by how dark it looked and ignored what was underneath it. Self-tan turns orange when the warm, yellow-brown tones of DHA develop with nothing to balance them. The fix is a base tone that cancels the orange before it starts: a violet or green undertone. That's the entire trick behind a tan that reads healthy instead of neon - and it's why all three of the looks below stay natural, at every depth.

Glazed

Dewy, lit-from-within, barely-there gold - the glazed-donut of tans. You want luminous, not deep; a glow people can't quite place. Build it slow and layered, like lip gloss, so it settles into a soft sheen rather than a statement.

Your shade: Blondie or Coconut Fudge, one light coat.

Latte

Warm, milky, coffee-with-oat-milk bronze. This is the everyday it-girl neutral - cozy, quietly expensive, never orange. It's the look that says you simply summer well, without ever announcing it. One honest coat and you're there.

Your shade: Noir Chocolate or Coconut Fudge.

Tomato girl

Sun-drenched, Mediterranean, a little flushed - like you wandered off a boat somewhere near Positano. Deep and warm, but built on a violet base so the red reads healthy, not brick. This is the deepest of the three, and the one where undertone does the most work.

Your shade: Mocha Melt.

Can't decide? You don't have to

Most people aren't one girl forever - you're glazed on a Tuesday and tomato by Saturday. That's the whole point of keeping two shades on hand. The Double-Dip Kit lets you pick any two and mix your depth to the day.

How to choose your self-tan shade, step by step

• Start with your undertone, not the color in the bottle. If you tend to go orange, choose a violet or green base.
• Match the depth to your natural skin, plus one or two steps. Fair skin glazes beautifully; deeper skin can carry latte and tomato with ease.
• Go lighter than you think for your first coat. You can always layer - you can't easily un-layer.
• Prep the same way every time: exfoliate, skip heavy moisturizer except on dry patches, apply with a mitt for an even finish.

Frequently asked questions

What shade of self-tan should I get?

Choose by undertone first, then depth. For a subtle glow go glazed (a light shade, one coat); for an everyday bronze go latte (a medium-dark coat); for a deep sun-drenched look go tomato (a dark, violet-based shade). Pick a depth one or two steps beyond your natural skin.

What is the most natural self-tan shade?

The most natural result comes from matching a violet or green undertone to your skin and not overshooting the depth. "Latte" - a warm medium bronze on a balanced base - reads most natural on the widest range of skin tones.

How do I stop my self-tan looking orange?

Orange comes from a warm formula with nothing to balance it. Choose a shade with a violet or green undertone, exfoliate before applying, and build in light layers rather than one heavy coat.

Can I mix self-tan shades?

Yes. Mixing lets you dial your depth precisely - a lighter shade to sheer out a dark one, or layer up for more. A two-shade kit makes this easy.

You're allowed to be a different girl next week. The glow goes on first; the rest of you follows.

Shop the shades →   Take 10% off with JULYGLOW, through July 31.

More from the Journal: How to fix a bad tan · How long does a tan actually last?